


if anyone wishes to argue, and I’m sure there are many good arguments that can be entertained. As could be possible of John Paul II, John Paul I, Paul VI, John XXIII, Pius XII etc. Of course I also acknowledge that Benedict XVI could also lose the office after valid election by virtue of obstinately holding to formal heresy publicly. I believe it should be obvious that I acknowledge that to be Benedict XVI. I haven’t read Marshall’s book, though I’m familiar with a lot of its content.Īs to the question of the last duly elected Pope – Thus Benedict should be called to explain and renounce his errors. According to this we can then move forward as to whether his resignation was valid, and even if he too is a heretic like Francis and whether or not he remains Pope, or also if he wishes to hold fast to the error that he can fundamentally change the Papal Office as to whether or not Benedict himself remains a Catholic. If the man has time to co-author books, then he can answer some bloody questions about his ‘resignation and the scandal he is responsible for producing by keeping all the visible signs and titles of the Papacy. Providing they get through Ganswein, of course, but nonetheless, the real first domino in this chain of an Antipapacy lies with Benedict alone, and he needs to be drilled. Instead of wasting precious time sending dubias to Francis who’ll never acknowledge them, faithful Catholics should change tactics and begin assaulting Benedict with dubias and questions to clarify a lot of what he intended. After all, to admit such colossal mistakes, I imagine would be enough to drive anyone into despair over what they’ve done. Both events in which he had a hand to play, and likely lives in denial.

It’s more likely he is touched by modernism himself and God’s providence allowed the screw-up to happen for the benefit of the sheep.īenedict is most likely a theologically compromised man, the perfect embodiment of the ‘conservative-Catholic’ cause where one is forced to serve two conflicting masters.īenedict wants to preserve the Vatican II council, and the suppression of the 3rd Secret of Fatima. Can’t get on board the Benedict-is-a-mastermind train.
